Further Procedures & Audit Evidence
Exam: CPA — Certified Public Accountant Chapter: Chapter 5 — AUD Further Procedures and Evidence Standards: AU-C 330 (Further Procedures); AU-C 500 (Audit Evidence); AU-C 505 (Confirmations) Last Updated: 2026-06-26
Key Takeaways
- Further audit procedures = tests of controls + substantive procedures
- Substantive procedures = substantive analytical procedures + tests of details
- Evidence must be both sufficient (enough of it) and appropriate (relevant and reliable)
- Reliability hierarchy: external > external-internal > internal; original > copy; direct > indirect
- Confirmations and physical examination are among the most reliable forms of evidence
Tests of Controls vs. Substantive Procedures
| Feature | Tests of Controls | Substantive Procedures |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Evaluate whether controls are operating effectively | Detect material misstatements in account balances, transactions, disclosures |
| When required | When auditor intends to rely on controls OR when substantive procedures alone cannot provide sufficient evidence | Always required for each significant account and disclosure |
| Addresses | Control risk | Detection risk |
| Examples | Inspect authorization signatures, re-perform approval process, observe segregation of duties | Confirm receivables, recalculate depreciation, inspect inventory |
Key rule: Tests of controls only reduce substantive procedures — they never eliminate the need for them entirely on significant accounts.
Substantive Analytical Procedures vs. Tests of Details
Both are substantive procedures, but they differ in application:
Substantive analytical procedures:
- Compare recorded amounts to the auditor's independent expectation (developed from prior periods, industry data, or relationships among data)
- Most effective when the auditor can develop a precise expectation
- Best for high-volume, predictable transactions (payroll,…
Keep reading: Further Procedures Evidence
Sign up free to read the full lesson, ask the AI tutor, and take practice questions.
- Full lesson content
- AI tutor for this section
- Practice questions